Are Democrats more likely to believe Astrology is a science?Are Fox News viewers more likely to believe...
Where does the expression "triple-A" comes from?
Is there a sentence that begins with “them”?
RP Automatic Updates
What's the biggest difference between these two photos?
How can "life" insurance prevent the cheapening of death?
Why is differential privacy defined over the exponential function?
Are the definite and indefinite integrals actually two different things? Where is the flaw in my understanding?
For how long could UK opposition parties prevent new elections?
A medieval fantasy adventurer lights a torch in a 100% pure oxygen room. What happens?
Two different colors in an Illustrator stroke / line
Do Milankovitch Cycles fully explain climate change?
How is the Team Scooby Doo funded?
Why would thermal imaging be used to locate the Chandrayaan-2 lander?
I changed a word from a source, how do I cite it correctly?
How can I protect myself in case of a human attack like the murders of the hikers Jespersen and Ueland in Morocco?
Stack class in Java 8
Is there a star over my head?
Improbable Inequalities
Are scroll bars dead in 2019?
Transitive Relations: Special case
How accurate is the new appraisal system?
How flexible are number-of-pages submission guidelines for conferences?
Creating a Master Image to roll out to 30 new Machines Licensing Issues
How to create a list of dictionaries from a dictionary with lists of different lengths
Are Democrats more likely to believe Astrology is a science?
Are Fox News viewers more likely to believe misinformation than viewers of other news outlets?In the USA, do supporters of the Republican party make more charitable donations than supporters of the Democrats?Are Americans more likely to be monolingual?Did political analyst, Larry Sabato ever say “The higher the education level, the more likely they are to vote Democratic.”?Are democrats more likely to commit crimes then republicans in the United States?Are white people who believe Obama is Muslim largely Trump sympathisers?Are physically attractive people more likely to be right wing politically?Are most US mass shooters Democrats?Are *some* Democrats talking about ending pre-existing condition protections?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0;
}
In an answer on politics.SE, a Northwestern University study was highlighted, whose main findings included:
more Democrats than Republicans think astrology is scientific
Using Fisher’s Exact Test, conservative Republicans are significantly more likely than other groups combined to reject astrology as not scientific (p<.0005). The same is true of conservatives compared to non-conservatives (p<.0005) and Republicans compared to non-Republicans (p<.0005). Likewise, Democrats are less likely to reject astrology as unscientific than others (p<.0005).
fewer Democrats than Republicans think the earth revolves around the sun.
...in 2012 a majority of Democrats (51.4%) could not
correctly answer both that the earth revolves around the Sun and that this takes a year. Republicans fare a bit better, with only 37.9% failing to get both correct.
One thing that does look a little dubious is that that this study was penned by a law professor. I'm also unsure if it has been published in a peer-review venue.
Are the results of this study consistent with other similar studies on such matters?
united-states politics education astrology
add a comment |
In an answer on politics.SE, a Northwestern University study was highlighted, whose main findings included:
more Democrats than Republicans think astrology is scientific
Using Fisher’s Exact Test, conservative Republicans are significantly more likely than other groups combined to reject astrology as not scientific (p<.0005). The same is true of conservatives compared to non-conservatives (p<.0005) and Republicans compared to non-Republicans (p<.0005). Likewise, Democrats are less likely to reject astrology as unscientific than others (p<.0005).
fewer Democrats than Republicans think the earth revolves around the sun.
...in 2012 a majority of Democrats (51.4%) could not
correctly answer both that the earth revolves around the Sun and that this takes a year. Republicans fare a bit better, with only 37.9% failing to get both correct.
One thing that does look a little dubious is that that this study was penned by a law professor. I'm also unsure if it has been published in a peer-review venue.
Are the results of this study consistent with other similar studies on such matters?
united-states politics education astrology
1
Comments that aren't about improving the question should be taken to chat. One's posted here are likely to be deleted.
– Oddthinking♦
9 hours ago
1
As a point of reference, part of what prodded the law professor to examine this was because (by my reading of a related article), apparently, belief in astrology over science is part of scoring in a number of measurements of conservatism (how conservative is someone), vs saying that one group is smarter or more knowledgeable than the other. He was examining this assumption more, so it seems like a legitimate examination. If we were looking to label a group as more or less scientifically ignorant, for lack of a better term, then the lack of examination of religion vs science would be notable.
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
On the other hand, Republicans are much more likely to believe in a Biblical god: pewforum.org/2018/04/25/…
– Daniel R. Collins
55 mins ago
add a comment |
In an answer on politics.SE, a Northwestern University study was highlighted, whose main findings included:
more Democrats than Republicans think astrology is scientific
Using Fisher’s Exact Test, conservative Republicans are significantly more likely than other groups combined to reject astrology as not scientific (p<.0005). The same is true of conservatives compared to non-conservatives (p<.0005) and Republicans compared to non-Republicans (p<.0005). Likewise, Democrats are less likely to reject astrology as unscientific than others (p<.0005).
fewer Democrats than Republicans think the earth revolves around the sun.
...in 2012 a majority of Democrats (51.4%) could not
correctly answer both that the earth revolves around the Sun and that this takes a year. Republicans fare a bit better, with only 37.9% failing to get both correct.
One thing that does look a little dubious is that that this study was penned by a law professor. I'm also unsure if it has been published in a peer-review venue.
Are the results of this study consistent with other similar studies on such matters?
united-states politics education astrology
In an answer on politics.SE, a Northwestern University study was highlighted, whose main findings included:
more Democrats than Republicans think astrology is scientific
Using Fisher’s Exact Test, conservative Republicans are significantly more likely than other groups combined to reject astrology as not scientific (p<.0005). The same is true of conservatives compared to non-conservatives (p<.0005) and Republicans compared to non-Republicans (p<.0005). Likewise, Democrats are less likely to reject astrology as unscientific than others (p<.0005).
fewer Democrats than Republicans think the earth revolves around the sun.
...in 2012 a majority of Democrats (51.4%) could not
correctly answer both that the earth revolves around the Sun and that this takes a year. Republicans fare a bit better, with only 37.9% failing to get both correct.
One thing that does look a little dubious is that that this study was penned by a law professor. I'm also unsure if it has been published in a peer-review venue.
Are the results of this study consistent with other similar studies on such matters?
united-states politics education astrology
united-states politics education astrology
edited 23 mins ago
lly
2462 silver badges8 bronze badges
2462 silver badges8 bronze badges
asked 11 hours ago
FizzFizz
12.3k3 gold badges46 silver badges92 bronze badges
12.3k3 gold badges46 silver badges92 bronze badges
1
Comments that aren't about improving the question should be taken to chat. One's posted here are likely to be deleted.
– Oddthinking♦
9 hours ago
1
As a point of reference, part of what prodded the law professor to examine this was because (by my reading of a related article), apparently, belief in astrology over science is part of scoring in a number of measurements of conservatism (how conservative is someone), vs saying that one group is smarter or more knowledgeable than the other. He was examining this assumption more, so it seems like a legitimate examination. If we were looking to label a group as more or less scientifically ignorant, for lack of a better term, then the lack of examination of religion vs science would be notable.
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
On the other hand, Republicans are much more likely to believe in a Biblical god: pewforum.org/2018/04/25/…
– Daniel R. Collins
55 mins ago
add a comment |
1
Comments that aren't about improving the question should be taken to chat. One's posted here are likely to be deleted.
– Oddthinking♦
9 hours ago
1
As a point of reference, part of what prodded the law professor to examine this was because (by my reading of a related article), apparently, belief in astrology over science is part of scoring in a number of measurements of conservatism (how conservative is someone), vs saying that one group is smarter or more knowledgeable than the other. He was examining this assumption more, so it seems like a legitimate examination. If we were looking to label a group as more or less scientifically ignorant, for lack of a better term, then the lack of examination of religion vs science would be notable.
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
On the other hand, Republicans are much more likely to believe in a Biblical god: pewforum.org/2018/04/25/…
– Daniel R. Collins
55 mins ago
1
1
Comments that aren't about improving the question should be taken to chat. One's posted here are likely to be deleted.
– Oddthinking♦
9 hours ago
Comments that aren't about improving the question should be taken to chat. One's posted here are likely to be deleted.
– Oddthinking♦
9 hours ago
1
1
As a point of reference, part of what prodded the law professor to examine this was because (by my reading of a related article), apparently, belief in astrology over science is part of scoring in a number of measurements of conservatism (how conservative is someone), vs saying that one group is smarter or more knowledgeable than the other. He was examining this assumption more, so it seems like a legitimate examination. If we were looking to label a group as more or less scientifically ignorant, for lack of a better term, then the lack of examination of religion vs science would be notable.
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
As a point of reference, part of what prodded the law professor to examine this was because (by my reading of a related article), apparently, belief in astrology over science is part of scoring in a number of measurements of conservatism (how conservative is someone), vs saying that one group is smarter or more knowledgeable than the other. He was examining this assumption more, so it seems like a legitimate examination. If we were looking to label a group as more or less scientifically ignorant, for lack of a better term, then the lack of examination of religion vs science would be notable.
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
On the other hand, Republicans are much more likely to believe in a Biblical god: pewforum.org/2018/04/25/…
– Daniel R. Collins
55 mins ago
On the other hand, Republicans are much more likely to believe in a Biblical god: pewforum.org/2018/04/25/…
– Daniel R. Collins
55 mins ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
Independently, Pew has discovered that a greater percentage of Democrats believe in astrology than Republicans:
They include details on their survey methods. They did provide a definition of astrology in the survey: "that the position of the stars and planets can affect people’s lives". This may rule out people confusing astronomy and astrology.
To summarize, this chart depicts that their findings were that 31% of Democrats and 14% of Republicans believe in astrology.
However, the bit about heliocentrism seems at odds with what I have seen before. This is just one study, but it concludes that political conservatism is a predictor of disbelief in Earth Science: Do Americans Believe Modern Earth Science? - Allan Mazur. In the table on predicting factors, it notes a small predictive effect from political conservatism for disbelief in heliocentrism.
7
It's very easy to draw invalid conclusions from a chart like this. As another Pew study shows, the Democrats receive more votes from female voters than the Republicans, and also more votes from black voters. These are two groups that also seem to have a relatively strong believe in astrology. Without a proper multivariate analysis, it's very difficult to disentangle these different variables.
– Schmuddi
6 hours ago
3
@Schmuddi Pew does weight their values: "The combined landline and cell phone sample is weighted using an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race/ethnicity, region, and population density to parameters from the March 2008 Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey."
– called2voyage
6 hours ago
10
Technically, the position of the stars and planets does affect people's lives. If the Sun suddenly moved 100 million kilometers closer or farther from the Earth, a lot of people would die. (This may suggest that nitpicking mathematicians are more likely than democrats to believe that that sentence is true).
– Federico Poloni
3 hours ago
8
I'd be interested to know how a "belief in yoga" is defined. I've had a number of physicians and physical therapists tell me that I need to take yoga, based on my astounding lack of lower body flexibility, and the type of results practicing yoga can give for that kind of body issue, and not in any way related to mystical powers. Does that mean they or I "believe in yoga?"
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
3
Playing devils advocate, suppose that Republicans don't believe in astrology because they believe the bible is literally true and prohibits fortune-telling. That obviously means Republicans are "more scientific" than Democrats, yes?
– alephzero
1 hour ago
|
show 11 more comments
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Independently, Pew has discovered that a greater percentage of Democrats believe in astrology than Republicans:
They include details on their survey methods. They did provide a definition of astrology in the survey: "that the position of the stars and planets can affect people’s lives". This may rule out people confusing astronomy and astrology.
To summarize, this chart depicts that their findings were that 31% of Democrats and 14% of Republicans believe in astrology.
However, the bit about heliocentrism seems at odds with what I have seen before. This is just one study, but it concludes that political conservatism is a predictor of disbelief in Earth Science: Do Americans Believe Modern Earth Science? - Allan Mazur. In the table on predicting factors, it notes a small predictive effect from political conservatism for disbelief in heliocentrism.
7
It's very easy to draw invalid conclusions from a chart like this. As another Pew study shows, the Democrats receive more votes from female voters than the Republicans, and also more votes from black voters. These are two groups that also seem to have a relatively strong believe in astrology. Without a proper multivariate analysis, it's very difficult to disentangle these different variables.
– Schmuddi
6 hours ago
3
@Schmuddi Pew does weight their values: "The combined landline and cell phone sample is weighted using an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race/ethnicity, region, and population density to parameters from the March 2008 Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey."
– called2voyage
6 hours ago
10
Technically, the position of the stars and planets does affect people's lives. If the Sun suddenly moved 100 million kilometers closer or farther from the Earth, a lot of people would die. (This may suggest that nitpicking mathematicians are more likely than democrats to believe that that sentence is true).
– Federico Poloni
3 hours ago
8
I'd be interested to know how a "belief in yoga" is defined. I've had a number of physicians and physical therapists tell me that I need to take yoga, based on my astounding lack of lower body flexibility, and the type of results practicing yoga can give for that kind of body issue, and not in any way related to mystical powers. Does that mean they or I "believe in yoga?"
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
3
Playing devils advocate, suppose that Republicans don't believe in astrology because they believe the bible is literally true and prohibits fortune-telling. That obviously means Republicans are "more scientific" than Democrats, yes?
– alephzero
1 hour ago
|
show 11 more comments
Independently, Pew has discovered that a greater percentage of Democrats believe in astrology than Republicans:
They include details on their survey methods. They did provide a definition of astrology in the survey: "that the position of the stars and planets can affect people’s lives". This may rule out people confusing astronomy and astrology.
To summarize, this chart depicts that their findings were that 31% of Democrats and 14% of Republicans believe in astrology.
However, the bit about heliocentrism seems at odds with what I have seen before. This is just one study, but it concludes that political conservatism is a predictor of disbelief in Earth Science: Do Americans Believe Modern Earth Science? - Allan Mazur. In the table on predicting factors, it notes a small predictive effect from political conservatism for disbelief in heliocentrism.
7
It's very easy to draw invalid conclusions from a chart like this. As another Pew study shows, the Democrats receive more votes from female voters than the Republicans, and also more votes from black voters. These are two groups that also seem to have a relatively strong believe in astrology. Without a proper multivariate analysis, it's very difficult to disentangle these different variables.
– Schmuddi
6 hours ago
3
@Schmuddi Pew does weight their values: "The combined landline and cell phone sample is weighted using an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race/ethnicity, region, and population density to parameters from the March 2008 Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey."
– called2voyage
6 hours ago
10
Technically, the position of the stars and planets does affect people's lives. If the Sun suddenly moved 100 million kilometers closer or farther from the Earth, a lot of people would die. (This may suggest that nitpicking mathematicians are more likely than democrats to believe that that sentence is true).
– Federico Poloni
3 hours ago
8
I'd be interested to know how a "belief in yoga" is defined. I've had a number of physicians and physical therapists tell me that I need to take yoga, based on my astounding lack of lower body flexibility, and the type of results practicing yoga can give for that kind of body issue, and not in any way related to mystical powers. Does that mean they or I "believe in yoga?"
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
3
Playing devils advocate, suppose that Republicans don't believe in astrology because they believe the bible is literally true and prohibits fortune-telling. That obviously means Republicans are "more scientific" than Democrats, yes?
– alephzero
1 hour ago
|
show 11 more comments
Independently, Pew has discovered that a greater percentage of Democrats believe in astrology than Republicans:
They include details on their survey methods. They did provide a definition of astrology in the survey: "that the position of the stars and planets can affect people’s lives". This may rule out people confusing astronomy and astrology.
To summarize, this chart depicts that their findings were that 31% of Democrats and 14% of Republicans believe in astrology.
However, the bit about heliocentrism seems at odds with what I have seen before. This is just one study, but it concludes that political conservatism is a predictor of disbelief in Earth Science: Do Americans Believe Modern Earth Science? - Allan Mazur. In the table on predicting factors, it notes a small predictive effect from political conservatism for disbelief in heliocentrism.
Independently, Pew has discovered that a greater percentage of Democrats believe in astrology than Republicans:
They include details on their survey methods. They did provide a definition of astrology in the survey: "that the position of the stars and planets can affect people’s lives". This may rule out people confusing astronomy and astrology.
To summarize, this chart depicts that their findings were that 31% of Democrats and 14% of Republicans believe in astrology.
However, the bit about heliocentrism seems at odds with what I have seen before. This is just one study, but it concludes that political conservatism is a predictor of disbelief in Earth Science: Do Americans Believe Modern Earth Science? - Allan Mazur. In the table on predicting factors, it notes a small predictive effect from political conservatism for disbelief in heliocentrism.
edited 8 hours ago
answered 9 hours ago
called2voyagecalled2voyage
9149 silver badges22 bronze badges
9149 silver badges22 bronze badges
7
It's very easy to draw invalid conclusions from a chart like this. As another Pew study shows, the Democrats receive more votes from female voters than the Republicans, and also more votes from black voters. These are two groups that also seem to have a relatively strong believe in astrology. Without a proper multivariate analysis, it's very difficult to disentangle these different variables.
– Schmuddi
6 hours ago
3
@Schmuddi Pew does weight their values: "The combined landline and cell phone sample is weighted using an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race/ethnicity, region, and population density to parameters from the March 2008 Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey."
– called2voyage
6 hours ago
10
Technically, the position of the stars and planets does affect people's lives. If the Sun suddenly moved 100 million kilometers closer or farther from the Earth, a lot of people would die. (This may suggest that nitpicking mathematicians are more likely than democrats to believe that that sentence is true).
– Federico Poloni
3 hours ago
8
I'd be interested to know how a "belief in yoga" is defined. I've had a number of physicians and physical therapists tell me that I need to take yoga, based on my astounding lack of lower body flexibility, and the type of results practicing yoga can give for that kind of body issue, and not in any way related to mystical powers. Does that mean they or I "believe in yoga?"
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
3
Playing devils advocate, suppose that Republicans don't believe in astrology because they believe the bible is literally true and prohibits fortune-telling. That obviously means Republicans are "more scientific" than Democrats, yes?
– alephzero
1 hour ago
|
show 11 more comments
7
It's very easy to draw invalid conclusions from a chart like this. As another Pew study shows, the Democrats receive more votes from female voters than the Republicans, and also more votes from black voters. These are two groups that also seem to have a relatively strong believe in astrology. Without a proper multivariate analysis, it's very difficult to disentangle these different variables.
– Schmuddi
6 hours ago
3
@Schmuddi Pew does weight their values: "The combined landline and cell phone sample is weighted using an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race/ethnicity, region, and population density to parameters from the March 2008 Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey."
– called2voyage
6 hours ago
10
Technically, the position of the stars and planets does affect people's lives. If the Sun suddenly moved 100 million kilometers closer or farther from the Earth, a lot of people would die. (This may suggest that nitpicking mathematicians are more likely than democrats to believe that that sentence is true).
– Federico Poloni
3 hours ago
8
I'd be interested to know how a "belief in yoga" is defined. I've had a number of physicians and physical therapists tell me that I need to take yoga, based on my astounding lack of lower body flexibility, and the type of results practicing yoga can give for that kind of body issue, and not in any way related to mystical powers. Does that mean they or I "believe in yoga?"
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
3
Playing devils advocate, suppose that Republicans don't believe in astrology because they believe the bible is literally true and prohibits fortune-telling. That obviously means Republicans are "more scientific" than Democrats, yes?
– alephzero
1 hour ago
7
7
It's very easy to draw invalid conclusions from a chart like this. As another Pew study shows, the Democrats receive more votes from female voters than the Republicans, and also more votes from black voters. These are two groups that also seem to have a relatively strong believe in astrology. Without a proper multivariate analysis, it's very difficult to disentangle these different variables.
– Schmuddi
6 hours ago
It's very easy to draw invalid conclusions from a chart like this. As another Pew study shows, the Democrats receive more votes from female voters than the Republicans, and also more votes from black voters. These are two groups that also seem to have a relatively strong believe in astrology. Without a proper multivariate analysis, it's very difficult to disentangle these different variables.
– Schmuddi
6 hours ago
3
3
@Schmuddi Pew does weight their values: "The combined landline and cell phone sample is weighted using an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race/ethnicity, region, and population density to parameters from the March 2008 Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey."
– called2voyage
6 hours ago
@Schmuddi Pew does weight their values: "The combined landline and cell phone sample is weighted using an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race/ethnicity, region, and population density to parameters from the March 2008 Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey."
– called2voyage
6 hours ago
10
10
Technically, the position of the stars and planets does affect people's lives. If the Sun suddenly moved 100 million kilometers closer or farther from the Earth, a lot of people would die. (This may suggest that nitpicking mathematicians are more likely than democrats to believe that that sentence is true).
– Federico Poloni
3 hours ago
Technically, the position of the stars and planets does affect people's lives. If the Sun suddenly moved 100 million kilometers closer or farther from the Earth, a lot of people would die. (This may suggest that nitpicking mathematicians are more likely than democrats to believe that that sentence is true).
– Federico Poloni
3 hours ago
8
8
I'd be interested to know how a "belief in yoga" is defined. I've had a number of physicians and physical therapists tell me that I need to take yoga, based on my astounding lack of lower body flexibility, and the type of results practicing yoga can give for that kind of body issue, and not in any way related to mystical powers. Does that mean they or I "believe in yoga?"
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
I'd be interested to know how a "belief in yoga" is defined. I've had a number of physicians and physical therapists tell me that I need to take yoga, based on my astounding lack of lower body flexibility, and the type of results practicing yoga can give for that kind of body issue, and not in any way related to mystical powers. Does that mean they or I "believe in yoga?"
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
3
3
Playing devils advocate, suppose that Republicans don't believe in astrology because they believe the bible is literally true and prohibits fortune-telling. That obviously means Republicans are "more scientific" than Democrats, yes?
– alephzero
1 hour ago
Playing devils advocate, suppose that Republicans don't believe in astrology because they believe the bible is literally true and prohibits fortune-telling. That obviously means Republicans are "more scientific" than Democrats, yes?
– alephzero
1 hour ago
|
show 11 more comments
1
Comments that aren't about improving the question should be taken to chat. One's posted here are likely to be deleted.
– Oddthinking♦
9 hours ago
1
As a point of reference, part of what prodded the law professor to examine this was because (by my reading of a related article), apparently, belief in astrology over science is part of scoring in a number of measurements of conservatism (how conservative is someone), vs saying that one group is smarter or more knowledgeable than the other. He was examining this assumption more, so it seems like a legitimate examination. If we were looking to label a group as more or less scientifically ignorant, for lack of a better term, then the lack of examination of religion vs science would be notable.
– PoloHoleSet
2 hours ago
On the other hand, Republicans are much more likely to believe in a Biblical god: pewforum.org/2018/04/25/…
– Daniel R. Collins
55 mins ago