Mdthbs

I am having trouble with the label locations on my commutative diagram.

Here is my code:

documentclass{article}



usepackage{tikz-cd}



begin{document}



begin{tikzcd}[ampersand replacement = &]

    0 arrow[r, "Nlambda", bend left] & 1 arrow[r, "(N - 1)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "lambda", bend left] & 2 arrow[r, "(N - 2)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "2lambda", bend left] & cdots arrow[r, "2lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "3lambda", bend left] & N-1 arrow[r, "lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "(N-1)lambda", bend left] & N arrow[l, "Nlambda", bend left]

end{tikzcd}



begin{tikzcd}[ampersand replacement = &]

    0 arrow[r, "Nlambda", bend left] & 1 arrow[r, "(N - 1)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "lambda", bend left] & 2 arrow[r, "(N - 2)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "2lambda", bend left] & 3 arrow[r, "2lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "3lambda", bend left] & 4 arrow[r, "lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "(N-1)lambda", bend left] & 5 arrow[l, "Nlambda", bend left]

end{tikzcd}



end{document}

which produces

I would like the arrow labels to appear "centered" on the arrows, as they are in the second diagram, but with the node labels from the first diagram. How can I fix this?

Note: I have already looked at the question here and know that I could probably manually correct the spacing on every single label, but that seems way more tedious than should be necessary given that I'm pretty sure the labels should be centered on the arrows by default.

What happens here? auto gets screwed up.

Why does it happen? See below.

Can one fix it? Yes, at least in an ad hoc way.

documentclass{article}

usepackage{tikz-cd}

tikzcdset{ad hoc fix/.style={r'/.style={r,/tikz/above},l'/.style={l,/tikz/below},

every label/.append style={/tikz/auto=false}}}



begin{document}

begin{tikzcd}[ampersand replacement=&,ad hoc fix]

    0 arrow[r', "Nlambda", bend left] & 

    1 arrow[r', "(N - 1)lambda", bend left] arrow[l', "lambda", bend left] & 

    2 arrow[r', "(N - 2)lambda", bend left] arrow[l', "2lambda", bend left] & 

    cdots arrow[r', "2lambda", bend left] arrow[l', "3lambda", bend left] & 

    N-1 arrow[r', "lambda", bend left] arrow[l', "(N-1)lambda", bend left] & 

    N arrow[l', "Nlambda", bend left]

end{tikzcd}



begin{tikzcd}[ampersand replacement = &]

    0 arrow[r, "Nlambda", bend left] & 1 arrow[r, "(N - 1)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "lambda", bend left] & 2 arrow[r, "(N - 2)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "2lambda", bend left] & 3 arrow[r, "2lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "3lambda", bend left] & 4 arrow[r, "lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "(N-1)lambda", bend left] & 5 arrow[l, "Nlambda", bend left]

end{tikzcd}

end{document}

The reason why this happens is that the arrows have different vertical positions of start and end points. This can be seen from

documentclass{article}



usepackage{tikz-cd}



begin{document}



begin{tikzcd}[ampersand replacement = &,every label/.append style={sloped}]

    0 arrow[r, "Nlambda", bend left] & 

    1 arrow[r, "(N - 1)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "lambda", bend left] & 

    2 arrow[r, "(N - 2)lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "2lambda", bend left] & 

    cdots arrow[r, "2lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "3lambda", bend left] & 

    N-1 arrow[r,"lambda", bend left] arrow[l, "(N-1)lambda", bend left] & 

    N arrow[l, "Nlambda", bend left]

end{tikzcd}



end{document}

Misplacement of arrow labels you can be reduce by increasing the bend angles. With this you slightly change the position of the start and end of the arrows for longer nodes' names. For example:

documentclass{article}

usepackage{tikz-cd}



begin{document}

    begin{tikzcd}[sep=large,

                   every arrow/.style={draw,->,bend left=45}, % for shorter diagram code

                   ]

0 ar[r, "Nlambda"]

    & 1 ar[r, "(N - 1)lambda"]

        ar[l, "lambda"]

        & 2 ar[r, "(N - 2)lambda"]

            ar[l, "2lambda"]

            & cdots ar[r, "2lambda"]

                     ar[l, "3lambda"]

                & N-1 ar[r, "lambda"]

                      ar[l, "(N-1)lambda"]

                    & N ar[l, "Nlambda"]

    end{tikzcd}

end{document}

Looks like a good application for tikz's chain library :

documentclass{article}

usepackage{tikz}

usetikzlibrary{automata,chains,positioning}

begin{document}



begin{tikzpicture}[

auto,

start chain = going right, 

state/.append style = { 

    on chain,

    draw=none,

},

]

node (s0)[state] {$0$};

node (s1)[state] {$1$};

node (s2)[state] {$2$};



draw[->] (s0) edge[bend left] node {$Nlambda$} (s1)

          (s1) edge[bend left] node {$lambda$} (s0)

          (s1) edge[bend left] node {$(N-1)lambda$} (s2)

          (s2) edge[bend left] node {$2lambda$} (s1)

          ;



end{tikzpicture}

end{document}